Grinding has been a part of gaming for decades at this point, and while players expect it in titles with RPG design elements to a degree, it’s not always managed well. Get it right, and grinding is both a fun part of the gameplay loop and a way for players to improve their skills and make meaningful progress. Get it wrong, and it’s a chore. So, what makes this difference?
When Rewards Are Few and Far Between
Grinding in any game has to come with regular rewards to break up the experience and also define the progress made, or else it’s just one long slog that leaves players with nothing to show for the work they’ve put in.
Getting the frequency of rewards right requires both a good sense of timing and an appreciation of what players will actually value. You’ll find this most often in an online casino gaming experience, where developers have built slots to be reliably random while also having algorithms that allow for a hit frequency that keeps players interested. It’s the equivalent of loot drops in an RPG, as combining the potential of getting a rare item with the need to grind a battle against a certain enemy mob, and adjusting the drop rate so that the experience is rewarding at the right intervals, works well.
When Setbacks Have Serious Consequences
For all the love that FromSoftware’s Souls series gets, it walks a tightrope in terms of how it handles grinding and progression. Specifically, because players must contend with a range of dangerous enemies and serious environmental hazards at all times, and death leads to all experience point-equivalent resources being dropped, with a second death erasing them for good, the consequences of even small mistakes can erase the work of hours of playtime.
Of course, this struggle is central to the design. But even FromSoftware has made changes to some of the least fair, least rewarding aspects of its games over the years. The long boss runbacks that were common in Demon’s Souls and early Dark Souls games were mercifully phased out in games like Elden Ring and Sekiro, for instance. Collecting dropped experience points was one thing, but having to spend several minutes getting back to a challenge only to die immediately felt like work, and the worst kind of work.
When Grinding is Mindless
Arguably the least appealing application of grinding for progress in games comes when the actions involved require no skill, or no real player interaction whatsoever. This is a common issue in MMORPGs and turn-based games, although it’s not unheard of in classic RPGs as well. Being able to level up agility and sneak in Oblivion by hammering jump or walking endlessly into a wall while crouched springs to mind.
Developers should really know exactly whether the grinding they’ve got in their game is fun and rewarding, or boring and workmanlike. Playtesting tends to throw light on such issues, and it’s down to teams to get creative in avoiding the latter scenario.